Xbox 360 MKV A/V desync
Forum rules
Please make sure you follow the Problem Reporting Guidelines before posting if you want a reply
Please make sure you follow the Problem Reporting Guidelines before posting if you want a reply
Xbox 360 MKV A/V desync
Spent several hours tonight trying to get MKV files to have synced audio on both PS3 Media Server and later UMS when I discovered it. Same results on both, no dice.
Rough specs:
3.4ghz, 4 processors, 4g ram, win7 64, wired connection
Basically with Mencoder the audio is running slightly slower than the video. Subtitles work as well as selecting audio channel. I have tried various checkboxes in Mencoder such as the A/V alternate method, disabling remux everywhere I can, etc.
First uninstalled all codecs and reinstalled Haali, CoreAVC, and FFDshow from individual installers. Same result.
Tried some of the matroska codec-specific parameters I found dealing with -nosync and the 23.597 FPS correction or whatever. Did not fix anything. Uninstalled all those codecs and reinstalled newest CCCP since at this point I had broken PC playback through screwing around, still same result.
Installed AVIsynth, when using AVIsynth/Mencoder as primary encoder the video runs much slower than the audio (opposite of previous problem).
At this point I tried Serviio, which out of the box synced perfectly but does not support subtitles or multiple audio streams so it's not an acceptable solution.
For what it's worth, forums seem to indicate I should be seeing Haali/FFDshow etc in my system tray when I am streaming through PMS/UMS, but I never do.
Let me know if I can provide any more information.
Rough specs:
3.4ghz, 4 processors, 4g ram, win7 64, wired connection
Basically with Mencoder the audio is running slightly slower than the video. Subtitles work as well as selecting audio channel. I have tried various checkboxes in Mencoder such as the A/V alternate method, disabling remux everywhere I can, etc.
First uninstalled all codecs and reinstalled Haali, CoreAVC, and FFDshow from individual installers. Same result.
Tried some of the matroska codec-specific parameters I found dealing with -nosync and the 23.597 FPS correction or whatever. Did not fix anything. Uninstalled all those codecs and reinstalled newest CCCP since at this point I had broken PC playback through screwing around, still same result.
Installed AVIsynth, when using AVIsynth/Mencoder as primary encoder the video runs much slower than the audio (opposite of previous problem).
At this point I tried Serviio, which out of the box synced perfectly but does not support subtitles or multiple audio streams so it's not an acceptable solution.
For what it's worth, forums seem to indicate I should be seeing Haali/FFDshow etc in my system tray when I am streaming through PMS/UMS, but I never do.
Let me know if I can provide any more information.
Re: Xbox 360 MKV A/V desync
Hi Mortis, welcome to the forums! 
Can you give me a name or link of one of the problematic files?
Can you give me a name or link of one of the problematic files?
Re: Xbox 360 MKV A/V desync
Thanks for the quick reply SubJunk. I feel like a bit of a toolbox now, it hadn't even occurred to me it might be the file. I just got done checking all the MKVs I currently have on my server and indeed the only one that noticeably desyncs early on is the one I was using for testing.
Here's a link to the offender: http://www.bakabt.com/149995-kuro-no-sh ... 4-acx.html
Within 30 seconds it becomes apparent it's desyncing and gradually getting worse.
I had assumed it was all MKVs because my roommate also installed PMS today and was getting really bad desync on all his MKVs as well, but they were large blu-ray rips. Is it possible his PC just wasn't up to it? It's quite a bit older than mine, I think an early dual core.
Here's a link to the offender: http://www.bakabt.com/149995-kuro-no-sh ... 4-acx.html
Within 30 seconds it becomes apparent it's desyncing and gradually getting worse.
I had assumed it was all MKVs because my roommate also installed PMS today and was getting really bad desync on all his MKVs as well, but they were large blu-ray rips. Is it possible his PC just wasn't up to it? It's quite a bit older than mine, I think an early dual core.
Re: Xbox 360 MKV A/V desync
I'm glad it's just that one, it's a reliefMortis wrote:Thanks for the quick reply SubJunk. I feel like a bit of a toolbox now, it hadn't even occurred to me it might be the file. I just got done checking all the MKVs I currently have on my server and indeed the only one that noticeably desyncs early on is the one I was using for testing.
Here's a link to the offender: http://www.bakabt.com/149995-kuro-no-sh ... 4-acx.html
Within 30 seconds it becomes apparent it's desyncing and gradually getting worse.
Downloading it now for testing, I'll reply when I've looked at it Usually if the hardware is too slow it would cause stuttering instead of desync. Sync that goes in and out usually means the network is too slow, while consistent desync usually means a strange file (rare codecs and/or codec settings)Mortis wrote:I had assumed it was all MKVs because my roommate also installed PMS today and was getting really bad desync on all his MKVs as well, but they were large blu-ray rips. Is it possible his PC just wasn't up to it? It's quite a bit older than mine, I think an early dual core.
Were they rips he had made himself, or also downloaded? If I get a name/link to one I can look at that too
Re: Xbox 360 MKV A/V desync
The file on the other PC that was wildly desynced was "Grosso guaio a Chinatown - Big Trouble in Little China [BDRip-1080p-MultiLang-MultiSub-Chapters][RiP By MaX].mkv," I'm not sure where he got it or why he got that version. I did watch a full MKV film this morning with no issues, though. Thanks for all your work on this software.